Holy Food to Inwardly Digest

It’s the most wonderful time of the year…

No, not Christmas, as department stores would have you believe. I am referring to Proper 28, of course! Every Sunday of the church year is numbered to identify the assigned Collect and scripture readings. And Proper 28 includes my very favorite Collect:

Blessed Lord, who caused all holy Scriptures to be written for our learning: Grant us so to hear them, read, mark, learn, and inwardly digest them, that we may embrace and ever hold fast the blessed hope of everlasting life, which you have given us in our Savior Jesus Christ.

This prayer was written by Thomas Cranmer, the first Archbishop of Canterbury, author-slash-compiler of the Book of Common prayer, and martyr to the cause of the newly-formed English Protestant Church of the sixteenth century.

I love this prayer for a couple of reasons. One is the broad theme of scripture, ordained by God and “written for our learning,” so that we can “ever hold fast to hope.”

It’s no surprise that someone like me would love a prayer that celebrates the Bible. As a born and raised Evangelical, my childhood faith was rooted in the “fundamentals” of a twentieth-century, Protestant movement known as “fundamentalism.” The first principle of fundamentalism is the belief in: “The inspiration of the Bible by the Holy Spirit and the inerrancy of Scripture as a result of this.” (“Innerancy” means “free from mistakes.”)

This belief about scripture is striking, not only because it isn’t the way Episcopalians usually interpret the Bible, but because it is the very first “fundamental” of fundamentalism. It comes before statements about the virgin birth, the crucifixion, the resurrection, and the reality of Christ’s miracles.

In that sense, it is flipped from an Episcopal approach to belief. Where Episcopalians say that the basic truth of our faith is found in the creeds developed by our spiritual ancestors, fundamentalists feel that church tradition is irrelevant to discerning truth. For them, the way to figure out what is true is to extract it straight out of the Bible. (Like their communion grape juice, they prefer a fresh-squeezed approach, rather than a fermented one.)

I actually don’t mean any of this as a takedown of fundamentalism. Because, while fundamentalism has come to be associated with a specific set of cultural and political values, its teaching on the Bible has surprising parallels to the church of Cranmer’s day. Cranmer was educated in a movement called “scholastic humanism” that helped usher in the renaissance, and what we think of as the “modern world.” One of the impacts of this school of thought was the desire to “go back to the source” to determine what was true.

In Cranmer’s day, many believed that the church had become bloated by traditions that distracted people from true faith: candles, processions, icons, relics, special prayers, never ending feast days, and even paying off the priests to help your dead family member get out of purgatory sooner, were common practices among Christians throughout Europe. Many people wanted to reclaim the version of Christianity that existed before it got tied up with all that ritual. And, for them, that meant going back to the Bible, studying it closely, and redeveloping long-held beliefs in light of what they found there.

While Cranmer wasn’t exactly a “fundamentalist,” he wanted to “go back to the source” to rediscover the heart of Christianity, so that he could guide his beloved church into a better future. Cranmer wanted all Christians to “hear, read, mark, learn, and inwardly digest” Scripture for the sake of discovering the truth that would set them free. And Episcopalians benefit from this legacy. Fundamentalists aren’t the only ones who get to take scripture seriously. It is for us, too.

And this is where we get to the second reason I love this prayer. It’s that wonderful phrase, “inwardly digest.” It makes us picture scripture as a kind of food. It’s full of nutrients that your body metabolizes. It contains some other parts that you might be tempted to expel. But, what you manage to “keep down” keeps your heart beating.

If scripture is something we “inwardly digest,” that means that scripture is “holy food.” We usually use that phrase for the bread and wine of Eucharist. But here, we see it related to scripture. Like communion, scripture can draw us closer to God and one another. But that doesn’t mean that all of it is enjoyable. In fact, parts of the Bible are hard to digest.

Take today’s Gospel reading…

This reading – as well as the one before and after it – are confusing and disturbing. The genre is literally called apocalypse. With all this talk of outer darkness, and weeping and gnashing of teeth, they sound very inconsistent with a God whose primary trait is love.

Today’s reading, the Parable of the Talents, is pretty well-known, because preachers like to use it as a reminder to give money to the church during stewardship season: “God wants your time, talent, and treasure.” But, this passage is not actually about “talent” in the modern sense – though, fun fact: this passage is where that word comes from. It is about power and exploitation, responsibility and punishment, fear and risk. And, strangely, also about financial investing. If you’re not sure what the heck is going on here, you’re not alone.

Well, the baseline is that a landowner gives his slaves large sums of money, called talents, and then leaves them. In his absence, they have to figure out what to do with all that money.

In reading the commentaries, there was no consensus on how to interpret this story: Andrew McGowan talked a lot about the first century economy. Daniel Harrington discussed early Christians’ interaction with the Jewish communities they had left behind (Sacra Pagina). Wesley Allen focused on the theme of responsibility, and how we should share our burdens with one another.

But, all of them agree on at least two points: 1. This is an allegory – a metaphorical story – where the Master stands in for Jesus and the slaves stand in for the Christian community, and, 2. this story was probably at least a little confusing for the original audience, just as it is for us.

That leaves us with a lot of questions. Why did different slaves receive different amounts of money? Why didn’t the Master tell anyone what his expectations were? Why was he so mad with that poor guy who didn’t actually lose any of the money? And maybe, most significantly, why does the story say: “For to all those who have, more will be given, but from those who have nothing, even what they have will be taken away.” When, a couple chapters earlier, Jesus said: “So the last will be first, and the first will be last.”

Isn’t this a contradiction? As we ask these questions, Cranmer’s words should come back to us. Cranmer suggests that when we’re confused or disturbed by certain passages – which he calls “dark mysteries” – the thing to do is: “hear them, read them, mark them up, learn more about them, and take a pause to inwardly digest.” In other words, when we are tempted to walk away, we should actually give it more time.

This week, I decided to put Cranmer’s advice to the test. I spent time reading, marking, and learning, and I’m happy to tell you that I have digested something. That’s not to say that I won’t understand it differently the next time I encounter the passage. In fact, I preached on it three years ago and came to a different conclusion.

But here’s what’s sticking with me today: Jesus tells this story to his disciples in anticipation of his departure. After he dies, he will rise and return to heaven. And at the last day, he will return again. But in the middle, there is a long and anxious wait. Jesus shares these parables with an eye toward that long wait. Like a soldier about to be deployed to a far-off land, Jesus is talking to his kids like they’re grown-ups, for the first time. He is making them aware of the work that they will need to do in his absence to ensure their thriving.

He is reminding them about the “family values,” encouraging them to live without fear, to take healthy risks, and to keep growing up, even in his absence. This is straight talk from God, and it intended to empower people who are likely to feel adrift without Jesus by their side.

In that sense, this story is ultimately a positive one. While it contains a warning, it is not fundamentally about punishment. It is Jesus’ reminder that he has given us the gift of divine love, and the cost of receiving that gift is not hoarding it, but spreading it around. Because that love, when shared, will grow exponentially, until our lives, in this world and the next, are utterly transformed.

Even bitter things can nourish us. That is the gift of Cranmer’s prayer, and the gift of these complex and wonderful scriptures. At first, this “holy food” might give you indigestion. But take a pause, and spend some time with it. Because it’ll keep your heart beating.

Amen.